Looking at the huge crowd gathered to hear him, Jesus asks his disciple Philip where they could possibly find enough food to feed the large crowd. As happens often in John’s Gospel, Jesus knows exactly what he is about to do so this question is a test for the disciples (John 6:6). Marianne Meye Thompson acknowledges the verb used here can refer to a temptation or trap, but in this cases it is better “examine, try, prove” (John, 140).
Once again in the Gospel of John someone misunderstands Jesus’s question and fails to anticipate the miracle. Philip points out the impossibility of buying that much food: “Two hundred denarii” worth of food would not be enough! This is more than a half-year’s wages, so Philip’s point is “we don’t have that kind of money, Jesus.” He is thinking of literally feeding the crowd, Jesus is talking about spiritually feeding the crowd the “bread of life.”
Another disciple who is only mentioned in the Synoptic gospels, Andrew, finds a boy with a small lunch. Andrew probably did not think the food could be shared, he was pointing out the impossibility of finding enough food for the crowd. The fish were probably small pickled fish (not a sardine, but something similar). No one would carry a pair of rainbow trout in their satchel on the outside chance they were needed to feed a crowd!
Jesus takes this small amount of food, offers thanks, and then distributes the food to the crowd. The crowd sees that is a miracle and wonder what kind of prophet Jesus is. They have in a mind a tradition drawn from Deut 18:15-18 that another prophet like Moses will come into the world. Moses fed the Israelites manna in the wilderness, in a similar way Jesus gives bread to a new Israel in a new wilderness.
Deuteronomy 18:15-18 (ESV) “The LORD your God will raise up for you a prophet like me from among you, from your brothers—it is to him you shall listen— 16 just as you desired of the LORD your God at Horeb on the day of the assembly, when you said, ‘Let me not hear again the voice of the LORD my God or see this great fire any more, lest I die.’ 17 And the LORD said to me, ‘They are right in what they have spoken. 18 I will raise up for them a prophet like you from among their brothers. And I will put my words in his mouth, and he shall speak to them all that I command him.
It is possible this miracle is an allusion to Elisha (2 Kings 4:42-44). In 2 Kings the prophet Elisha feeds 150 men with a small amount of food. There are similarities, but the more important allusion is to the wilderness period of Israel’s history.
The food provides enough for all the crowd to eat until they are satisfied and still have twelve baskets left over. Consider these are poor people who are given free food and allowed to eat as much as they want. I think they probably overate and maybe stuffed a few leftovers in their pockets to take home to the family.
The point of the leftovers? “This is the ample provision of the Lord who declared, ‘My people will be filled with the bounty’ (Jeremiah 31:14)” (Carson, John, 271). Just as Jesus provided plentiful excellent wine at the wedding in Cana (John 2:1-12) and healed a man who was crippled for thirty-eight years (5:5-6), now Jesus provides enough food everyone is satisfied and there are plenty of leftovers. Like the wine at the wedding in Cana, Jesus is revealing for those who have ears to hear that he is the host of an eschatological banquet, like the manna in the wilderness God is providing new bread for his people. But as Jesus will say later in John 6 this “bread of life” is his own body which will be given for them (6:48-51).
I definitely think the point of leftover bread was to shows Jesus ability to provide an abundance of bread just as God provided in the account of Mosses and Elisha. Kostenberger explains that Jesus’s nourishment of the 5000 reveals that he is the giver of eternal life (Kostenberger, 100). Meaning that the bread that comes form Jesus is the bread that will fill our stomachs and never leave us hungry. Jesus’s miracle was not just to show his divine powers but was to teach the people a vital lesson that he is the new bread of life. Just as God filled the stomachs of the Israelite’s who followed Him into the wilderness Jesus also provided for those who followed him into the wilderness. These characteristics are also seen in the account of Elisha where she faced the task of feeding 100 men. God provided for the men with an abundance of bread when there was a sense of uncertainty in the narrative of Elisha. The same uncertainty and questioning that was presented in Johns narrative before the feeding the 5000. So yes I believe Johns narrative is an allusion to Elisha account due to similarities in both narratives. Overall the left over bread shows that Jesus is the new bread of life and has the same provision as God during the times of Moses.
It is so cool to see the connection that Jesus makes many times throughout his ministry as him being the bread of life. In the end he ties it all back to the last supper where the disciples are actually eating bread while Jesus is explaining that this is his body. I can only imagine the lightbulbs that were going off remembering back to the day when Jesus fed 5,000 people and gave them more than enough. Like it is mentioned, this mirracle wasn’t exactly about feeding people or about food, but was to show that Jesus is the bread of life. That he is enough and more than enough for what we need for life, for eternal life! The connection that Jesus was making to the OT was and should have ben a clue to the people of what Jesus was doing. Andrew and Philip should have right away noticed that Jesus was asking soemthing impossible, and they should have remembered the story of Israel in the wilderness being fed everyday with manna from heaven. They seem to forget this at the beggining and Jesus had to remind them of this reality. This mirracle shows that yes, God does provide for our physical needs and we can trust him for that, but also that Jesus is more than enough for us.
While there are, especially in the book of John, many symbols that represent the deity of Christ easily found in His miracles, we should also take note that these miracles were actually in themselves spectacular. The agenda of Christ was, of course, not merely to entertain, but I’m sure some of the miracles He performed were more than amusing! I believe this is so with the particular example of the feeding of the five thousand. Christ, while always on a spiritual level, was trying to demonstrate His deity and confirm the faith of His disciples, the fact of the miracle is nevertheless spectacular. There is a tendency among scholars and private interpreters of the Bible to view everything as a symbol or as merely a means to understanding some spiritual truth. While this is true, I think it reduces the originality and awesomeness of the Bible! Jesus fed five thousand people, and while it is important to understand that Christ was communicating His providence and messiahship through this miracle, it is nevertheless a spectacular phenomenon! However, against this argument, I think the reason for the leftovers was especially symbolic–for Christ knew exactly how much food that each person in the crowd was going to eat. He could have manufactured just the right amount. Jesus deliberately chose to create leftovers to signify that when He provides for His people, He is not frugal. Yes, God does provide for our needs, but He also gives us more than enough (Jeremiah 31:14). Kostenberger also makes the point that when we work for Jesus, our labor is never in vain because He rewards us appropriately. Let us, therefore, work for God diligently, knowing that He will astonish us with His endless resources.
From what we know about Jesus, He is the student who does not just fulfill the requirements; He is that overachiever that messes with all our grades! (Insert laughing emoji). On a real note, when God fed the Israelites in the desert, the manna would melt away when the Sun got hot; anything they gathered in disobedience would rot (Exodus 16:20). This was a way of making sure Moses and the Israelites trusted God with all their provisions or “everyday bread”.
In 2 Kings 4:42-45, Elisha follows instructions from God to feed 100 men. In this case, Elisha had a man, from Baal-shalishah, bring him twenty loaves of barley and fresh ears of grain from his first crops. Elisha started with a lot more than Jesus did and only had 100 men to feed. The similarity is still present because the men were all fed and there was more leftover.
One cannot argue that what Jesus did was superior in nature, but for people who had heard these things happening before wondered if He was just another prophet. For people who were used to seeing miracles, this miracle was not that special. They were more worried about being full. As mentioned in the post, these people were most likely poor people who follow Jesus around because they could rely on His provision whether that be physical or spiritual. This makes me think about Bloom’s Taxonomy from Psychology. Maslow shows in his hierarchy of needs that physiological needs, in this case, food, is at the very bottom. This is a need that must be fulfilled before a person can move up in any way. Jesus says the He is the “bread of life” (John 6:35) which using Maslow’s Hierarchy of needs is saying that we need Him to be the foundation of our spiritual life (Matthew 6:33). He is the “food” or “spiritual bread” in our life.
The point of the leftovers was very clear to me, to prove just the kind of miracles that jesus can do. If we look back at the prophet Elisha, we see the same story, with the same outcome. isn’t it crazy that Jesus performs the same miracles, once done by prophets and then predicted would happen once the King came to live on earth? It is very fascinating to me, yet also Jesus came to provide food for us. Yes, although Jesus himself provided literal food for the multitude of people, he also provided his body, as “leftovers” for the followers of him. This is yet another time, I think that Jesus provides a story, a miracle that shows just how clever he really was. Almost all of his stories have hidden meanings that are not clear to anyone during the time they are given and this is creative to note. Jesus performs the miracles as a lesson for those watching, not to boast and gain all this attention, he truly wants to change lives, just like his death changed many lives after his death.
I like how Jesus asked Philip how to feed the great crowd. Jesus invited his disciples into the process of faith. Jesus could have just told them how He was going to provide the food and drink, but instead he gave asked Philip a question to stir his and the other disciples faith.
I also liked how John included how much this would have costs to feed everyone- more than half a years wages!
This is insane! I think that John wanted us to see how if the disciples tried to feed other through their own strength, it would not go very well. That is like the same thing for us today, when we try to accomplish things through our own abilities.
When Andrew then sees the little boys lunch of two fish and five loaves of bread, it is interesting how Andrew suggests the idea, but right after he does he asks, “but how far will they go among so many people?”
Sometimes we have the faith to see the provisions of the Lord, but we then we let doubt creep in on how it will come to fruition.
I love how it says that Jesus gave thanks before He distributed the bread. Before the miracle happened, Jesus thanked the Father.
Jesus saw thankfulness to the Father as important, for the provision was from the Father for the people to see the glory of the Lord.
The last think that I saw as interesting was that when Jesus was distributing the bread, He gave to the people as much as they wanted. He did not hold back, but gave them an abundance of food to fill their bellies.
Just like Jesus gave an abundance of bread and fish to the people, He also give life and life abundantly!
Let us have more faith that He loves us and He will continue to provide for us.
I like how Jesus asked Philip how to feed the great crowd. Jesus invited his disciples into the process of faith. Jesus could have just told them how He was going to provide the food and drink, but instead he gave asked Philip a question to stir his and the other disciples faith.
I also liked how John included how much this would have costs to feed everyone- more than half a years wages!
This is insane! I think that John wanted us to see how if the disciples tried to feed other through their own strength, it would not go very well. That is like the same thing for us today, when we try to accomplish things through our own abilities.
When Andrew then sees the little boys lunch of two fish and five loaves of bread, it is interesting how Andrew suggests the idea, but right after he does he asks, “but how far will they go among so many people?”
Sometimes we have the faith to see the provisions of the Lord, but we then we let doubt creep in on how it will come to fruition.
I love how it says that Jesus gave thanks before He distributed the bread. Before the miracle happened, Jesus thanked the Father.
Jesus saw thankfulness to the Father as important, for the provision was from the Father for the people to see the glory of the Lord.
The last think that I saw as interesting was that when Jesus was distributing the bread, He gave to the people as much as they wanted. He did not hold back, but gave them an abundance of food to fill their bellies.
Just like Jesus gave an abundance of bread and fish to the people, He also give life and life abundantly!
Let us have more faith that He loves us and He will continue to provide for us.
The interesting question is, “what is the point of the leftovers after the feeding of the 5000?” I honestly have never thought about this question and I love that it was brought up because it truly illustrates the pro-founding truth that God does provide. By just ending the story with the fact that everyone was fed and full would have been outstanding enough, but no, he decided to add in the fact that there were leftovers. A common biblical illustration that I thought of when reading this question was Jesus makes our cups overflow. He constantly gives us more than we deserve, but why? Because he loves us, he cherishes us, wants the best for us, he wants to prove us wrong! This past year I look back at many moments I went through and I always include in my prayers, “thank you Father for proving me wrong.” Because too many times we doubt that God is not gonna supply our entire need, or our need at all, but every single time he proves us wrong. He gives to us abundantly, he makes our cup overflow, we see leftovers every single time, and to be honest I need to be more diligent in noticing those leftovers more often because truly they are signs of the greatest blessings!
Jesus’s miracle of feeding the 5000 is a great example of His divine nature and His compassion for people. I think that it’s really cool that Jesus asked Phillip about how they could feed the crowd, Phillip mentions to Jesus that there’s no way that they would be able to purchase enough food for the people who were in need. So they find bread and fish in a boys lunch box, which wasn’t a lot. Jesus preformed a miracle and fed the 5000 with twelve baskets leftover. I’ve never really put much thought into what the leftovers mean or what it symbolizes. I think that the leftovers symbolizes that Jesus always satisfies His believers just like with the wine at the wedding in Cana. Jesus also shows here that he provides for his people. Jesus later on mentions that “bread of life” is his own body which will be given for them (6:48-51). I think this miracle is just an example of how Jesus is the “bread of life” meaning that He is enough for us and through him and only him do we have eternal life. I think another thing that we can take from this miracle and knowing that there was leftovers is that our problems are never too big for God, even when we think that something isn’t possible we need to remember that everything is possible through Jesus. He cares for us and will provide for us.
I like how Jesus was testing his disciple to see if he understood what he was saying about feeding the crowd. Phillip is thinking that Jesus wants him to go purchase food, as he tells Jesus that he would need a great amount of Denarii to purchase that amount of food for the huge crowd. Jesus is talking about the bread of life, meaning Jesus himself. We as Christians can often times think that we understand and know that this is what God is telling us. It is good to sit and meditate to understand clearly and not have a foggy understanding. It is so amazing that Jesus was talking about the bread of life. Jesus is abundant and he is enough to go around. He will never leave or forget us. He wants us to come to him every day and even the unbelievers. Jesus won’t say no to anyone and the bread of life is fresh every day and it will never run out. I have noticed that there are some Christians that can be negative and make it seem as if the bread of life isn’t for everyone, and it’s so cool to see that Jesus was testing his disciples. Just as he tested his disciples God test’s us in our daily lives as well. When we are tested we may not always understand but in the end God always show us the painted picture for us to understand.
It’s so funny, isn’t it? When we talk about the miracle of Jesus feeding the 5,000, we focus on the grand nature of the miracle, as we should. It’s an awe-inspiring, wondrous display of Jesus’s ability to completely change our circumstances and shows how He provides for our needs. But what is seldom talked about, as mentioned in this blog post, is the significance of the leftovers. As mentioned in the post, there is an intentionality about Jesus, throughout the course of this event. As pointed out in the post, and in John 6:6: “He said this to test him, for he himself knew what he would do.” (John 6:6, ESV). Was Jesus testing the recipients of this feast with these leftovers? I don’t believe we are given a clear answer. However, I think there are some great inferences we can make. For one, this is a wondrous display is Jesus providing more than we needed, more than we could possibly imagine. Sometimes we try to limit what God can do, sometimes we unknowingly limit what God can do because we limit Him to our human standards, when in reality we provide above and beyond anything we could imagine. Also, what Jesus could also be communicating by providing leftovers is what do we do when God blesses us with “extra?” Do we get greedy, and keep the abundance for ourselves? Or, is our natural heart posture one of giving, and being able to bless others as God has blessed us?
Whenever I read this story, I always think that the reason there was so much food leftover was to show how amazing Jesus is and that He will not only provide for the people what they need, but will also provide for them in abundance. This is such an incredible story that shows not only the love of Jesus, but also His power. I think that the parallels to Moses should not be overlooked because there may be a reason for that, but I like that John does not come right out and say that this is like Moses. Instead, he keeps the focus on Jesus so that the audience can learn more about Him. I also think that Jesus feeding the crowd “the bread of life” is something that is really cool to think about. It is easy to read this story and just think about the fish and bread that they are eating, but when you look at it as Jesus spiritually feeding them, you can get a whole new perspective on the story. It is a fun story for kids to learn because it shows something miraculous that Jesus did, but usually, they leave out some of the details when telling kids. This completely makes sense to me because they don’t understand everything, but I think that there is so much to look at in this section and it is good to dive deeper into this story as adults.
Throughout the miracles of Jesus, he never does a miracle that proves to be the bare minimum. Everything that Jesus does is to show the power, grace, and mercy that He possess from the Father. The first sign where Jesus turns water into wine, he produces much more wine that is necessary and is not all consumed during the celebration when it is finished. When he heals the sick child, he does so not even have the child in his physical presence. The child is healed by the faith of the solider and mere words. When Jesus heals the man at the pool of Bethesda, he does not perform the miracle the same way that other religious figures had done in the past through the healing water, he simply commands him to pick up his matt and walk. When Jesus feeds the 5000, he is showing his love for those that choose to listen. When he is faced with the hungry masses, he requests that the disciples gather what food they can find. The disciples can see the improbability that this task will be possible, but Jesus overcomes all objections and provides enough food that there are twelve baskets remaining. Jesus provides more than what was just needed everything given in abundance, much like the love of Christ is more than we deserve.
In several of Jesus’s miracles, Jesus not only meets the expectations, but he greatly exceeds them. The miracle of the Feeding of the 5,000 is not an exception to this pattern. It is amazing to me that Jesus provided enough food to feed 5,000 men, plus food for women and children, and there was still enough for 12 baskets of leftovers. What was the point of the leftovers? I believe that part of the reason is that Jesus displayed his divine power by not only providing enough food for everyone, but by exceeding the amount necessary to feed everyone. This is something that can be applied to our lives, in that we can trust that God will give us everything we need, and He sometimes will give us more than what we ask for. In addition, Jesus provided the leftover bread as a parallel between the manna that God provided for the Israelites in the wilderness. Just as God gave manna to Moses and the Israelites, Jesus provided enough food for the 5,000. Jesus’s provision of the leftover bread also illustrates that Jesus is the bread of life. Ultimately, the physical food that we have on earth is not as important as the bread of life that Jesus gives us. Because of Jesus, we are able to have an eternal relationship with God if we rely on him to fulfill our spiritual and physical needs. Jesus cares greatly about each of his children, and He will always provide us with what we need in order to accomplish God’s will for our lives.
I believe that the point of the leftovers correlates to Jesus’ point of feeding the 5000 spiritually, aka the bread of life. First, I find it funny how it was common for Jesus to ask questions in which he already knew the answer to. This reminds me of how patient of a teacher Jesus was. Second, the importance of feeding the crowd the bread of life is very significant in the leftovers. This significance makes me think of the abundance of forgiveness, love, and mercy that Jesus has for us. Not only does He spiritually feed us, but there is never a ‘cap off’ to His supply. He never says to us, “You’re hungry? Here is some food, but only take this much.” In other words, He never says to us, “Your sins are forgiven…but only this one and that one, and half of this one.” Does this make sense? I believe that the leftovers of food was a symbol of the Lord’s abundant character. I appreciate the point that was made saying that the crowd most likely overate, yet there were still leftovers! Personally, I have found it so kind of the Lord that when we are spiritually hungry, He provides so much more than what we can imagine. I am so undeserving of His forgiveness, love, and mercy; not only does He still provide these things for me, but He provides an abundance of them (2 Cor 9:8, Eph 3:20). It is His nature to abound in love and faithfulness (Exodus 34:6)!! So, in conclusion, I would say that the point of the leftovers is that there is an abundance of leftovers when we are hungry for the Lord and His character.
Another consideration for this is what practical purpose might the leftovers have served. As you have said here John tends to highlight the excellence of Jesus’ miracles and demonstrates their incredible power. No miracle like this in John could be considered a minor miracle if there is such a thing. However, are the leftovers the result of Jesus aiming to create an impressive miracle? Surly he in his knowledge would realize that he had made more than enough, yet he chooses to continue to divide fishes and loaves. In a practical sense it seems unlikely that Jesus is stocking up on provisions for himself and his disciples here, as not long after this they have no bread, and as far as I am aware Jesus does not provide miraculous refrigeration for the food he created. My personal theory is that the leftovers likely would have been gathered to demonstrate Jesus’ abundant provision to the disciples and then it would have been distributed to the crowd as they still had to journey home. Though this is only speculation based on the fact that later the disciples and Jesus have no bread despite the abundant leftovers.
My first question whenever this passage is mentioned is… what did the kid think? These grown adults just took his lunch box and made it multiply by A LOT. Was he chill? Did he find it cool that it was his lunchbox? Did he brag? I just want to know what he thought and if he became a believer after that.
But on a real note, this miracle has many correlations to the Old Testament and this helps to prove who Jesus truly is… God. Throughout all of John, as we have been talking John is drawing out more and more examples of how Jesus is God. This sign not only draws him back to the wilderness period since he is providing bread, just as God did to the Israelites. But it also just simply shows Jesus doing a miracle to prove he is God. The Word Biblical Commentary mentions how in John it is not mentioned that Jesus had compassion, it says that this could be due to John expecting his readers to already know this information from Mark. But because John had a very specific mission with his gospel to him it could have felt like unnecessary information, whereas Mark thought it was important. But again that is just my assumption, as John does leave out the entire dialogue prior to the Feeding of the 5000. Throughout the entire book of John, he stays very focused on his mission and does not stray from it. It also shows that he very well could have known of the other gospels at the time he wrote his.